Truth in IT
    • Sign In
    • Register
        • Videos
        • Channels
        • Pages
        • Galleries
        • News
        • Events
        • All
Truth in IT Truth in IT
  • Data Management ▼
    • Converged Infrastructure
    • DevOps
    • Networking
    • Storage
    • Virtualization
  • Cybersecurity ▼
    • Application Security
    • Backup & Recovery
    • Data Security
    • Identity & Access Management (IAM)
    • Zero Trust
    • Compliance & GRC
    • Endpoint Security
  • Cloud ▼
    • Hybrid Cloud
    • Private Cloud
    • Public Cloud
  • Webinar Library
  • TiPs
  • DRAW
  • CPE

Fortra: When a Notebook Defeats Your Entire Security Stack

Fortra
07/05/2026
0 (0%)
Share
  • Comments
  • Download
  • Transcript
Report Like Favorite
  • Share/Embed
  • Email
Link
Embed

Transcript


and this would be close to the example that you gave about yourself, Tyler, a woman manages to infiltrate a company that sort of does lending to people. Now, it's not one of the major banks. It's one that sort of does, you know, subprime kind of, you know, not payday loan, but just barely above that, giving people mortgages and loans and stuff. So they were getting all kinds of applications in with all the sensitive data that you have to put into those things. And they had great physical security. They couldn't plug a USB in, they had firewalls, they had everything else. This woman was coming in and you know how she was getting the information and using it to apply for credit cards? Notebook and pen. Nobody thought about a notebook and pen. She was sitting in front of her computer at lunch and writing down the information. And the only reason that she got caught was her boyfriend was also putting in fraudulent credit card applications. The cops busted into their apartment, found her notebook. So you see what I'm talking about here. I mean, that's not something a technical control is gonna fix, but it's something process will fix, right? You're sort of, first of all, better vetting of who applies for a job there. And also you can notice if somebody's sitting there taking a notebook, right? Taking, you know, writing stuff down in a notebook. So these are the things we worry about and you know, physical security is a part of this too.

TL;DR

  • A lending company with strong technical controls — firewalls, USB restrictions, physical security — was breached by an insider who simply wrote down customer data with a notebook and pen.
  • The attacker was only caught because her boyfriend's separate fraud triggered a police investigation, not because any security control detected her activity.
  • Technical controls alone cannot stop analog data exfiltration; process improvements like behavioral monitoring and rigorous employee vetting are essential complements to any security stack.

Summary

In this short clip from The Art of Security podcast, Brent Arnold of INQ Law recounts a real-world insider threat case that exposes a fundamental gap in technology-centric security strategies. A woman working at a subprime lending company — an organization that processed sensitive financial applications and had robust technical controls including firewalls, USB port restrictions, and physical access security — bypassed every single safeguard using nothing more than a notebook and a pen. During lunch breaks, she would manually copy applicant data from her screen and later use it to apply for fraudulent credit cards. She was only caught because her boyfriend was independently submitting fraudulent applications, leading police to their apartment and the incriminating notebook. Arnold's takeaway is direct: no technical control can prevent someone from writing things down. The fix lies in process and people — better pre-employment vetting, behavioral observation on the floor, and recognizing that physical security must account for analog threats, not just digital ones. For organizations that believe a strong security stack equals a secure environment, this case is a pointed reminder that human behavior remains the most exploitable attack surface of all.

Chapters

0:00 - The Breach Setup
0:25 - Strong Tech, Zero Protection
0:38 - Notebook and Pen
0:54 - Process Over Technology

Key Quotes

0:38 "Notebook and pen. Nobody thought about a notebook and pen."
0:56 "That's not something a technical control is gonna fix, but it's something process will fix, right? ..."
1:01 "Better vetting of who applies for a job there. And also you can notice if somebody's sitting there taking a notebook, right? ..."

FAQ

How was the insider threat in this story eventually discovered?

The attacker was not caught by any security system. Police investigating her boyfriend's separate fraudulent credit card applications raided their apartment and found her notebook containing the stolen customer data.

What controls could have prevented this type of analog data theft?

According to Brent Arnold, process-level controls are the answer — specifically better pre-employment background vetting and behavioral observation on the floor to notice employees manually copying information from their screens.


Categories:
  • » Data Protection » Backup & Recovery
  • » Data Protection
Channels:
News:
Events:
Tags:
  • Security Operations
  • Data Protection
  • Best Practices
  • Short Form
  • Insider Threat
  • Physical Security
  • Human Behavior Risk
  • Data Exfiltration
  • Security Controls Limitations
  • Employee Vetting
  • Analog Attack Vectors
Show more Show less

Browse videos

  • Related
  • Featured
  • By date
  • Most viewed
  • Top rated
  •  

              Video's comments: Fortra: When a Notebook Defeats Your Entire Security Stack

              How secure is your Microsoft enterprise? Under 5 minutes, earn $10 in TruthPoints.

              View CPE Certificates

              Upcoming 360 View Events

              • Nov
                19

                Securing the Microsoft Enterprise: Strengthening Configuration Management, Identity Security, and Data Protection

                11/19/202601:00 PM ET
                More events

                XStreaminars (watch here)

                • Dec
                  09

                  Beyond Continuous Compliance: Getting Ready to Detect, Recalculate, and Adapt

                  12/09/202601:00 PM ET
                  More events

                  Industry Events (Sponsor Hosted)

                  • Nov
                    18

                    Hands-On Workshop: Connecting On-Prem Data to Databricks via MinIO AIStor (International)

                    11/18/202608:00 AM ET
                    • Nov
                      19

                      Zendesk Deep Dive: Get the work done faster with Employee Service AI Agents

                      11/19/202601:00 PM ET
                      • Nov
                        19

                        AI Agent Showdown: Discover What Muse, Dots, and Duet Bring to Your Website

                        11/19/202601:00 PM ET
                        • Dec
                          02

                          Skylight en acción: salvaguardando la IA más allá del usuario.

                          12/02/202604:00 AM ET
                          • Dec
                            03

                            CISO Insights: Steering Cybersecurity Strategies in an AI-Driven Era

                            12/03/202601:00 PM ET
                            More events

                            Upcoming Webinar Calendar

                            • 11/18/2026
                              08:00 AM
                              11/18/2026
                              Hands-On Workshop: Connecting On-Prem Data to Databricks via MinIO AIStor (International)
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2194/hands-on-workshop-connecting-on-prem-data-to-databricks-via-minio-aistor-international/
                            • 11/19/2026
                              01:00 PM
                              11/19/2026
                              Securing the Microsoft Enterprise: Strengthening Configuration Management, Identity Security, and Data Protection
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2076/securing-the-microsoft-enterprise-strengthening-configuration-management-identity-security-and-data-protection/
                            • 11/19/2026
                              01:00 PM
                              11/19/2026
                              Zendesk Deep Dive: Get the work done faster with Employee Service AI Agents
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2181/zendesk-deep-dive-get-the-work-done-faster-with-employee-service-ai-agents/
                            • 11/19/2026
                              01:00 PM
                              11/19/2026
                              AI Agent Showdown: Discover What Muse, Dots, and Duet Bring to Your Website
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2228/ai-agent-showdown-discover-what-muse-dots-and-duet-bring-to-your-website/
                            • 12/02/2026
                              04:00 AM
                              12/02/2026
                              Skylight en acción: salvaguardando la IA más allá del usuario.
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2147/skylight-en-acción-salvaguardando-la-ia-más-allá-del-usuario/
                            • 12/03/2026
                              01:00 PM
                              12/03/2026
                              CISO Insights: Steering Cybersecurity Strategies in an AI-Driven Era
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2231/ciso-insights-steering-cybersecurity-strategies-in-an-ai-driven-era/
                            • 12/09/2026
                              01:00 PM
                              12/09/2026
                              Beyond Continuous Compliance: Getting Ready to Detect, Recalculate, and Adapt
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2250/beyond-continuous-compliance-getting-ready-to-detect-recalculate-and-adapt/
                            • 12/09/2026
                              02:00 PM
                              12/09/2026
                              Strategies for Safeguarding Endpoints in the Agentic Era with Cyera
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2256/strategies-for-safeguarding-endpoints-in-the-agentic-era-with-cyera/
                            • 01/19/2027
                              04:00 AM
                              01/19/2027
                              Skylight in Aktion: Gewährleisten Sie KI-Schutz über den Benutzer hinaus
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2176/skylight-in-aktion-gewährleisten-sie-ki-schutz-über-den-benutzer-hinaus/
                            • 01/19/2027
                              02:00 PM
                              01/19/2027
                              HUMAN Dialogue: Embracing the Rise of the Empowered AI Consumer.
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2160/human-dialogue-embracing-the-rise-of-the-empowered-ai-consumer/
                            • 03/18/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              03/18/2027
                              Securing Access for People, Partners and AI Agents
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2251/securing-access-for-people-partners-and-ai-agents/
                            • 06/17/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              06/17/2027
                              Stop the Leak: Data Loss Prevention for the AI Era
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/955/360view-stop-the-leak-data-loss-prevention-for-the-ai-era/
                            • 08/19/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              08/19/2027
                              Who Has Access to What...and Should They?
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2252/who-has-access-to-what-and-should-they/
                            • 10/21/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              10/21/2027
                              After VMware: Building the Private Cloud You Actually Want
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2253/after-vmware-building-the-private-cloud-you-actually-want/
                            • 11/18/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              11/18/2027
                              Assume Breach, Prove Recovery
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2254/assume-breach-prove-recovery/
                            • 12/16/2027
                              01:00 PM
                              12/16/2027
                              The Self-Running Service Desk
                              https://www.truthinit.com/index.php/channel/2255/the-self-running-service-desk/
                            Truth in IT
                            • Sponsor
                            • About Us
                            • Terms of Service
                            • Privacy Policy
                            • Contact Us
                            • Preference Management
                            Desktop version
                            Standard version